
But only at the right price and for the short term. No more than 4 years, or the Canadian can take his pasty skin and Canadian-ness elsewhere. Why Bay? Everyone knows
he's a defensive nightmare and I love me some good run saving, so am I just totally running counter to my already established beliefs? Well, yes and no. For starters, my liking of him stems from the fact that he's not Matt Holliday.
I don't deny that Matt Holliday
could hit in the AL, but his tenure in Oakland
was wholly underwhelming when it came to proving that fact. Moreover, the terms of the Holliday deal are a bit worrisome. He's demanding a 6 year deal, by most accounts, which would mean he'd be 36 when the contract is up. His defense is certainly nothing special either, but the problem of moving him to DH is that the Yankees will have other players in 6 years' time that might need to make a similar shift. Alex Rodriguez comes to mind on that front. Or Derek Jeter depending on how long he is resigned for when that time comes. So in that respect, the Yankees might get stuck with a logjam at DH, or be forced to trot another creaky-kneed LF out on a regular basis. That's frightening to me.
Bay though is rumored to be demanding a contract more oriented on the short-term and for fewer dollars. Say the Yankees give him a 4 year deal? He'd still be old when the deal came due, but the four years (rather than 6) would give the Yankees a bit more a bubble when it comes to their aging players having to transition away from playing the field.
Plus, Bay has proven he can hit in the AL, boasting a fantastic
.397 wOBA in his first full year with Boston. Coupled with his ability as a run producer (34.9 RAR in 2009), he could immediately fill the lineup hole left by a departing Hideki Matsui. Plus, he's less of an injury risk than Matsui and that's automatically quite appealing.
Now, the Yankees can deal with his defensive situation in two ways, I think:
1.) Re-sign Johnny Damon , who can at least boast of having "range," and stick him out in LF as a platoon with Bay in that position and also at DH. This would require hoping the combination of Brett Gardner and Melky Cabrera can help to cover up any defensive inadequacies; however, it would also allow for the Yankees to keep their productive top of the order from 2009 with Bay now in the number 5 spot.
2.) Don't resign Damon. Move Melky to left, Gardner in center and Bay as the DH/part-time leftfielder. This is obviously the better defensive outfield, but the loss of Damon and the full-time addition of Gardner to the batting order could mean a lot less runs scored for the Pinstripes.
What do you think?